The adventures (and misadventures) of a girl who thinks too much for her own good...

Sunday, December 21, 2014

What You're Not Getting About #BlackLivesMatter and #BlueLivesMatter


I'm so sick of everyone's misguided self-righteous crap. Sick of everyone pointing their finger at any cause but the correct one. Sick of improper blame.
Let's state some facts first. Plain and simple: Eric Garner and Michael Brown were small-time criminals who did not deserve to die during their final encounters with the police. The law should have been applied to them and they should have had the chance to go to court for their minor transgressions – they shouldn't be lying in coffins because two racist cops with God-complexes used excessive force against them. Those specific officers should have faced repercussions for their actions yet neither will stand before a jury – and that is wrong. It is a perpetuation of a defect in our society that allows typically white officers off the hook whenever they use brutality against minority citizens – and it is morally wrong and it needs to be addressed and stopped.
HOWEVER – none of what I just said at all ever justifies the cold blooded murder of two police officers. The deaths of Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos are an unspeakable disgusting travesty, and my heart hurts just as much for the injustice perpetrated against them as it did for the injustice perpetrated during the Garner and Brown cases. Calling open season on anyone in a uniform is just as senseless and immoral as shooting/hitting first and asking questions later in encounters with unarmed black men. It's wrong and it's heartbreaking what happened to these two police officers and I wish there was something we could do to give justice to their families – but that's not an option either since the cowardly bastard killed himself after the murders.
As for the outrage against public figures like Bill Deblasio and Al Sharpton and Eric Holder – I'll say this. Granted, I don't know DeBlasio or Holder or Sharpton personally. I don't know what goes on in their heads. But I can pretty much guarantee that they are fundamentally NOT "anti-cop." You know who is "anti-cop?" Criminals. Pop-culture criminals like Tony Montana, as well as real-life criminals like Bonnie and Clyde or Al Capone – these slimeballs were most definitely "anti-cop" and yet we still idolize and glorify their criminal prowess today. People who seek out elected positions in government are not "anti-cop" – but sometimes they are "anti-cops-not-being-held-accountable-for-their-brutality-against-the-citizens-they-are-supposed-to-be-protecting." And that's what is happening here.
By supporting the right for people to protest against unnecessary violence perpetrated against minority citizens by police, Bill DeBlasio and Eric Holder are not being "anti-cop" – they are being "pro-justice." Yes - the protests were mostly an inconvenience to people in the city not actively protesting, but they had been primarily peaceful until that despicable incident on the Brooklyn Bridge and this tragic assassination of two officers. None of the people in charge of organizing these protests has been calling for violence against police – they have in fact been speaking out against it since the beginning. The families of Michael Brown and Eric Garner have said plainly that violence against police as well as looting/damaging property is NOT the answer and they do not support it as revenge for their slain relatives. As American citizens we have the right to protest peacefully, so blaming these police deaths on the Mayor or blowhards like Sharpton because they support protests against a real problem like police brutality is like blaming Martin Luther King Jr. for any black civilian deaths that occurred during clashes throughout the civil rights movement because he defended equal rights for all people regardless of race – you can't blame public figures for defending First Amendment rights guaranteed to us in the damn Constitution.
Nobody wants to label this for what it is because of the tension that's been clouding everyone's judgment since the summer of 2014. This is yet again another sad case of an evil individual – a violent repeat offender who should have had no access at all whatsoever to a firearm- acting out against his imagined enemies. Now two admirable men have died in the line of duty at the hands of a monster, and for what? To me their deaths are akin to the pointless slaughter of the children and staff of Newtown Elementary by a madman who mistakenly blamed the school for his troubles – there were plenty of signs that something nefarious was going on with these killers and sadly innocent people paid the price just by showing up to work.
The bottom line that few people are getting is this – it is an undeniable fact that people in positions of authority are capable of corruption. WE CANNOT EVER PLACE ABSOLUTE TRUST IN POLICE OR CLERGY OR LAWMAKERS – WE ARE ALL HUMAN AND IMPERFECT. Most people in positions of authority do not abuse their power and are good, kind people just trying to make a difference – but there are plenty of bad apples. These individuals should be punished for their transgressions just like the rest of us – they shouldn't be allowed to abuse their power. 
All people regardless of color should have the law applied to them equally – and it isn't that way and it has never been that way. Look no further than the Twitter hastag #crimingwhilewhite. Historically: minority peoples have been abused and mistreated since (and prior to) the founding of our nation in 1776 – and it's time for the injustice to end. Ideas like "#BlackLivesMatter" are a call for justice and fairness, not for retribution against police. #BlueLivesMatter is of course a worthwhile cause as well - but these social media ideas are not parallel and are speaking for different agendas. The movement against police brutality and for police accountability is not in any way a cry for police mistreatment or disrespect towards police. No one is saying that black lives are more important than the lives of police officers, nor more important than white lives or Asian or Hispanic lives. The agenda of #BlackLivesMatter is to make people aware that often minority citizens are mistreated by people in positions of authority simply because they are black or brown, and in certain terrible situations these abuses result in the unjustified deaths of black people as in the Garner and Brown cases. The agenda of the majority of people using #BlueLivesMatter is to express outrage that the authority of the police was ever questioned in the first place – and that is a dangerous mindset. 
If the people who are charged with our safety are never checked – what you have is tyranny, not respect. The murders of these two NYPD officers should not be blamed on a peaceful movement – they should be blamed on the soulless criminal that killed them - on the defects at large in our society. A society that glorifies gun-violence and criminal behavior and a society that does a piss poor job of preventing gun-related tragedies because the people who make our laws are slaves to campaign donors like the NRA. 

No comments:

Post a Comment